Federal Judge Frees Canadian Dentist Wrongly Detained by ICE Over Misdirected Notice
A Green Card Interview Turned Into a Nightmare
Dr. William Lizardo, a Canadian dentist detained by U.S. federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in Minnesota during a green card interview, is back home after being ordered released by a federal judge. The case quickly drew national attention — not just because of who was arrested, but because of how and why it happened.
According to court filings, Lizardo came to the United States in 2019 on an F-1 student visa to study at the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry. A relative petition on his behalf was approved in January 2025. He was doing everything right — going through proper legal channels — when the system failed him in a fundamental way.
A Bureaucratic Error With Devastating Consequences
Orders to appear at subsequent immigration hearings were sent to the wrong address. Lizardo missed those hearings and was subsequently arrested by ICE on October 23, detained at Sherburne County Jail, and ordered removed from the U.S. An immigration court later determined that Lizardo missed the appearance through no fault of his own.
Lizardo had practiced dentistry in federally-designated shortage areas until his work authorization was revoked, at which time he started volunteering at a low-cost clinic in Burnsville, Minnesota, according to court documents. Far from a flight risk, he had built deep roots in the community. The judge cited Lizardo’s family, his free dental services to Minnesota residents, and more than a dozen letters of support in the record.
The Judge’s Scathing Ruling
Judge Michael J. Davis ordered Lizardo’s release in response to a writ of habeas corpus, concluding that the 32-year-old was not a flight risk and that his Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights were being violated while he was held in Sherburne County. The judge did not mince words. He wrote, “Because the facts presented here are so appalling and so well supported, the Court could issue a long order, complete with colorful details about, and commentary on, the abuses suffered by Petitioner.”
Davis ordered officials to release Lizardo in Minnesota no later than 6 p.m. Sunday and prohibited the government from detaining, transferring, or removing him again without first obtaining permission from the court. Even then, compliance wasn’t immediate. Sherburne County Jail indicated it would not release Lizardo despite being provided the federal court order because it “had to wait for ICE.” Lizardo’s lawyer, Hassan Ahmad, confirmed that his client was finally released Sunday evening, hours after the judge’s order.
What Comes Next
Ahmad says Lizardo cannot be detained again by ICE while he is waiting for the decision on his green card. His attorney has been clear about what he believes the government should do. “This whole removal proceedings was tainted from the very beginning,” Ahmad said, adding that he hopes ICE will just let it go.
The ruling does not grant Lizardo permanent residency or resolve his underlying immigration case. He hopes to open a clinic in rural Minnesota with his wife, whom he met at dental school. The case stands as a stark example of how administrative errors within the immigration system can cascade into life-altering consequences — and how the federal courts remain a critical check on enforcement overreach. For others caught in similar bureaucratic traps, the ruling shows that a person in that position can ask a federal court to review the detention while the immigration case continues.


