Arkansas Official Charged With 65 Felonies for Rigging Bar Exam Scores Over Five Years
A Gatekeeper Gone Rogue
Nancie Givens, the former executive director of the Arkansas Office of Professional Programs, was charged on November 5 with 65 felony counts of tampering with public records following an investigation into alleged bar exam score alterations. The case has sent shockwaves through the legal community — not just in Arkansas, but across the country — because the person accused of manipulating the system was the very person entrusted to protect it.
According to investigative details disclosed by six members of the Arkansas Supreme Court, the alleged manipulation affected at least eight bar examination administrations, raising questions about the integrity of the process used to determine who is qualified to practice law in Arkansas. Givens resigned from her role in February 2026 and allegedly deleted or modified around 11,400 files and electronic communications to cover her tracks.
How the Scheme Allegedly Worked
Evidence exists, prosecutors say, that Givens “harvested points from a number of examinees’ scores and then added them to other examinees’ scores within the same test administration.” In plain terms: she allegedly stole points from some test-takers and gave them to others. According to the justices, the alleged manipulation resulted in some applicants receiving scores of at least 270 — the minimum passing score for the Arkansas Bar Examination — while the review also identified at least one instance in which alterations may have lowered an applicant’s score from passing to failing.
In another instance, an examinee who should have received the highest score on an examination allegedly had points deducted, resulting in another applicant being identified as having the highest score. When investigators began closing in, they found that about 11,400 files had been deleted or made unavailable in early January 2026 — most of them bar exam applications, applicant profiles, and score sheets that court rules require the office to retain for 25 years. A state police investigator’s affidavit said that after 8,100 files were restored, investigators found irregularities including “manually altered bar exam scores.”
The Ripple Effect on Lawyers and Clients
The questions extend far beyond one former court official and the criminal case against her — reaching into the lives of aspiring attorneys who may have been denied opportunities they earned, lawyers who may have entered the profession under inaccurate qualifications, and clients who trusted those lawyers to represent them. For five years, examinees relied on a system they believed would accurately determine whether they were qualified to practice law.
According to an affidavit, Givens allegedly tampered with as many as 64 Arkansas Bar Examination scores. Investigators who compared recovered records discovered manually altered bar exam scores for at least 64 people, resulting in a different bar exam score from what they actually earned. Authorities have stated that the vast majority of examinees who were told they passed did, in fact, pass the exam, and that those affected will be notified by the Office of Professional Conduct as soon as possible upon definitive confirmation of their status.
What Comes Next
The findings were referred to state and federal authorities, leading to a criminal investigation launched in April by Arkansas State Police and the FBI. Givens has entered a not guilty plea to the charges, according to court records. She has also been referred to the Office of Professional Conduct for an investigation into potential violations of the Arkansas Rules of Professional Conduct, separate from the criminal investigation.
The justices said they are working with state and federal authorities to recover deleted data, review all bar exam administrations during the period in question, and determine the full extent of what they described as a serious and potentially criminal abuse of power. The February 2026 administration of the Arkansas Bar Exam already put new testing procedures and security measures in place to strengthen accountability and protect the integrity of the examination. The harder question — what to do about lawyers already practicing whose licenses may rest on fraudulent scores — remains unanswered, and its resolution could set a precedent that reverberates through bar licensing systems nationwide.


