Cold Case Solved After 13 Years as Suspect Arrested in Phoenix Security Guard’s Murder
A Family’s Long Wait for Justice
Nearly 13 years after unarmed security guard Jeffrey Bellemare was shot and killed while on the job at a Maryvale apartment complex, Phoenix police say they’ve made an arrest in the cold case. For the Bellemare family, the news brought a wave of complicated emotions — relief, grief, and something in between. “It’s always been a hard time of year for us,” Bellemare’s family member Karan told reporters. “You never get over it. All of us feel bittersweet. We miss him. He’s missing out on things he should be here for.”
The arrest is especially emotional for the Bellemare family because it is occurring so close to Thanksgiving and the 13th anniversary of Bellemare’s murder — he died while working the overnight shift, which had begun on Thanksgiving Day. Bellemare, 59, had left Thanksgiving dinner to work that overnight security shift at the Phoenix apartment complex. It was a sacrifice that cost him his life, and one his family never forgot.
The Night of the Murder and the Long Investigation
On November 29, 2013, at around 1:30 a.m., Bellemare was shot and killed while on the job, working as an unarmed, uniformed security guard at Graybriar Apartments near 55th Avenue and Indian School Road. For years, the case went cold. In the months and years following the incident, Phoenix Police homicide detectives worked tirelessly in the pursuit of numerous leads related to the murder, but a breakthrough remained elusive.
In early 2026, a new female witness came forward who said that she was a teenager in 2013 and had seen a male and a female at an apartment in the complex minutes before the shooting. The new witness identified the suspect in a photographic lineup. A man who was in an apartment with the new witness the night Bellemare was killed was also interviewed and told investigators that a man named “Tweety” came to the apartment with a woman — and that person told police they heard people say “Tweety” was responsible for Bellemare’s killing, and identified the suspect as “Tweety.”
The Arrest
Phoenix Police announced the arrest of 43-year-old Joe Gerardo in Globe, ending a 13-year cold case investigation into the fatal shooting of Jeffrey Bellemare. Police took Gerardo into custody in Globe on November 3 and booked him into jail on a first-degree murder charge. His bond was set at $2 million cash. Investigators have not disclosed a motive or specified the full details of the new information that broke the cold case after 13 years.
Karan said that she’s certain God played a role in keeping up interest in the case, and she’s grateful that the Phoenix Police Department never gave up. “There were times when I think they were very shorthanded in the Phoenix Police Department, but having said that, they never stopped working on Jeff’s case,” she said. Karan had not heard of Gerardo until police informed her of the arrest.
What Comes Next
The Bellemare family is not certain whether there might be more arrests in the case. Investigators also reported that Gerardo owned a 1993 Chrysler Imperial with front-end damage, though court documents do not say whether DNA contributed to his arrest. As the legal process moves forward, the family faces another Thanksgiving season shadowed by loss — only this time, with the knowledge that someone has finally been held accountable.
Cold cases like this one serve as a reminder that witnesses hold enormous power. A single person, willing to come forward years later, can change everything. For the Bellemare family, justice arrived 13 years late — but it arrived. Whether more answers follow may depend on what unfolds in a Maricopa County courtroom in the months ahead.


