Former Miss Michigan Sounds the Alarm on Miss Universe After Pageant Scandal Erupts
A Crown With a Warning Label
The crown may look glamorous, but one former Miss USA contestant is warning aspiring beauty queens that what’s waiting beyond the national competition may not be worth the risk. Taylor Hale, who was crowned Miss Michigan USA in 2021, isn’t discouraging young women from competing — but she has a stark warning about chasing the Miss Universe dream.
“Because as Miss USA, you have to go to Miss Universe and that is a whole other ball game that I wouldn’t want to touch with a 10-foot pole,” Hale told Fox News Digital. She said she still hopes women pursue the pageant path — “I hope you win your state pageant” — but made her remarks ahead of the premiere of TLC’s documentary “Crown of Deceit: Inside the Miss Universe Scandal.”
What Happened Behind the Scenes
While competing as Miss Michigan USA in 2021, Hale said she experienced sexual harassment from Max Sebrechts, vice president of Miss USA at the time, the morning after she failed to advance to the finals. At the time, Sebrechts was married to Crystle Stewart, the then-head of the Miss USA organization. Sebrechts has denied all allegations of sexual harassment and misconduct made against him by former pageant contestants.
It took Hale some time to decide whether to go public. “I’ve talked about what happened before, and there’s a real fear on my end of letting this define me,” she explained. Hale is also notable as the first Black woman to win “Big Brother” in 2022, and she has been deliberate about not allowing the pageant chapter of her life to overshadow everything else she has accomplished.
A Docuseries Pulling Back the Curtain
According to PEOPLE, “Crown of Deceit” focuses on multiple controversies that have surrounded the Miss Universe organization in recent years, featuring “exclusive interviews with former contestants, pageant insiders, and whistleblowers, along with behind-the-scenes access,” examining “claims of intimidation, secret NDAs and leadership failures.” Miss USA 2023 Noelia Voigt and Miss Indiana USA 2008 contestant Brittany Mason also tell their stories in the series alongside Hale.
Omar Harfouch, a Miss Universe judge who made headlines when he abruptly resigned just before the 2025 pageant, also appears in the documentary. The documentary additionally revisits the 2025 Miss Universe controversy involving Mexico’s Fátima Bosch, when several contestants walked off the stage after an official publicly criticized her. The full series is available to stream on TLC and HBO Max.
Reform or Rebuild From Scratch?
Hale was careful to distinguish between the two organizations. “I really, really like the new director,” she said. “I think Thom Brodeur is a really great director. He cares about the women and the well-being of all the girls, teen and miss.” But her praise for Miss USA’s leadership came with a much harsher verdict for the international body.
When it comes to Miss Universe, Hale was blunt: “Miss Universe has to, I think, be burned to the ground and then rebuilt from the ashes.” She also called for structural change, saying “We need more sponsors that are not just charitable, but actually invested in real business practices,” and pointed to Halle Berry as an example of the opportunities pageants can provide, arguing that young women shouldn’t have to choose between pursuing those opportunities and feeling protected. For an institution that has long sold the promise of empowerment, that is a challenge it can no longer afford to ignore.


