How a 1973 Boston Crime Film Shaped John Turturro’s New Thriller
A Classic That Never Gets Old
Some movies don’t just entertain — they become blueprints. The Friends of Eddie Coyle, Peter Yates’s 1973 neo-noir crime drama, is one of those films. Robert Mitchum plays the title role as a low-level Boston criminal looking for a way to avoid a prison sentence. Film critic Ty Burr has called the 1973 film “the first Boston crime movie and the template for everything that followed.” Now, more than five decades later, it has found a new generation of admirers — including the cast and crew behind one of 2026’s most acclaimed crime films.
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is a 2026 American crime thriller written and directed by Noah Segan, starring John Turturro, Giancarlo Esposito, Will Price, Tatiana Maslany, and Steve Buscemi. At the Toronto International Film Festival, director Segan name-checked The Friends of Eddie Coyle as a key inspiration. The connection runs deeper than a casual reference — it shaped the film’s entire DNA.
A Shared Cinematic Language
Cinematographer Sam Levy recalled that when he first met Segan, one of the first films the director brought up was The Friends of Eddie Coyle starring Robert Mitchum — “a fantastic crime thriller from the ’70s set in Boston,” and one Levy was happy Segan mentioned because, as he put it, “it’s wonderful and not obvious.”
With its melancholy themes and doomed characters stuck in circumstances beyond their control, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York has its roots in classic film noirs and neo-noirs of yesteryear, and Turturro himself cites The Friends of Eddie Coyle as an inspiration for his somber performance. Turturro also drew inspiration from Robert Mitchum himself for the role. That’s a full-circle tribute — Mitchum starred in both films, separated by more than 50 years.
The Only Living Pickpocket is described as a modern relative of Peter Yates’s iconic film, as well as desperate and sweaty crime films like Straight Time and Cutter’s Way. Another cinematic touchstone the team discussed was Robert Bresson’s L’Argent — an arty crime thriller — particularly for its close-up shots, since “Harry is always doing stuff with his hands.”
The Story of Harry Lehman
Harry Lehman (John Turturro) is an aging pickpocket who plies his trade with ever-diminishing returns in a drastically changed New York. When he unwittingly steals and fences a valuable USB stick, Harry finds himself in a race against time to return the loot or face the rage of a vengeful crime family. Segan’s film is an unapologetic love letter to the city, with Turturro playing an aging thief whose old-school tactics become less effective in an age of two-factor authentication.
To prepare for the role, Turturro practiced with Apollo Robbins, a famed sleight-of-hand artist who coached him on the art of misdirection. “He really helped me, gave me exercises, and worked with me,” Turturro said. According to The Hollywood Reporter‘s David Rooney, “Turturro is unshowy but magnificent in his best film role in years, an honorable hustler who still carries himself with dignity despite a lifetime of regrets.”
Critical Acclaim and a Lasting Legacy
The film was acquired by Sony Pictures Classics following its Sundance debut, where critics praised its gritty authenticity and ability to tell a crime story without relying on violence. Rotten Tomatoes’ critical consensus reads: “A graceful character study that affords John Turturro one of the best roles of his career, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York astutely captures the struggle to scrape by in a world that won’t stop changing the rules.”
The through-line from Eddie Coyle to The Only Living Pickpocket says something meaningful about what endures in crime cinema. The 1973 Boston-based original introduced viewers to a seamy underworld of scheming career criminals on a downward spiral, featuring Mitchum as a 50-year-old New England gunrunner trying to avoid prison. Variety has described Segan’s new film as something that “feels like a new, minor-key New York classic.” If that’s true, then the tradition of gritty, character-driven American crime filmmaking — one that began


