A Historic Shift in How Americans See Crime

Americans are increasingly optimistic about the nation’s crime trends, with perceptions of rising crime hovering near historic lows even as nearly half the country still believes crime is getting worse, according to a new Gallup poll. The findings, released Monday, November 16, represent a remarkable turnaround in public sentiment that has been building for several years.

Just 46% of Americans now believe there’s more crime nationally than a year ago — the lowest reading in 25 years. And just a third of people said crime in their local area was getting worse, the fourth-lowest mark in Gallup tracking going back more than 50 years. To put that in historical context, Americans were most negative about national crime in 1992, when 89% said it was rising.

The Partisan Divide Is Shrinking

Just two years ago, Republicans and Democrats were sharply divided over whether national crime was increasing. Those differences narrowed last year, and Republicans’ perceptions of rising national crime fell another 15 percentage points in the latest survey. That’s a striking development in an era defined by political polarization on nearly every issue.

Still, the shift isn’t happening in a vacuum. Data shows Republicans are driving the decline, following a decades-old pattern of party members shifting their views under new presidential administrations. People report being less afraid of walking around at night and believing crime rates are lower in their neighborhood when their political party runs the Executive Branch. In other words, perception of crime has long been tangled up with who sits in the White House.

What Americans Actually Fear Most

The poll also highlights a shift in what Americans fear most: financial crimes continue to generate considerably more concern than violent offenses. Gallup asked Americans about 10 types of crime, and topping the list of concerns were identity theft and scams — the only crimes that most Americans said they worry about at least occasionally.

Americans’ worries about most types of crime are down from the recent highs reached in 2022 and 2023, though adults aged 18 to 34 are the most worried age group on seven of the eight crimes measured. The report also showed that younger adults, people with lower incomes, and women were more likely to believe that crime was getting worse nationally.

Reality vs. Perception

The findings, based on an October 1–19 survey, come as federal crime statistics show substantial declines in violence across the country. Experts note that public perception of crime has historically lagged behind actual crime data — people’s fears are shaped by media coverage, political messaging, and personal experience as much as by statistics.

One analyst noted that “messaging” from the administration, think tanks, and the media has reinforced the idea that crime is declining — and he’s not surprised to see Americans less concerned about crime where they live than they are about crime nationally, because “most people mostly don’t see crime, because it’s not typical.” As public confidence in personal safety continues to climb, the bigger question may be whether policymakers and communities can sustain the conditions — real and perceived — that are driving this rare moment of national optimism.